About SAO and SAO Career OpportunitiesNewsroomAudits and ReportsEventsAuditor's Confidential LineContact UsHome
The Public
Town Government
Legislature, Governor & Administration
The Press
Audit Community
Vermont Municipal Advisory Committee
County Sheriff Reports
email this page
print this page

Newsroom

Commentary: Decision-making process must change with the times

Auditor Tom Salmon speaks on the process of reform

May 13, 2009

By Thomas M. Salmon, CPA
Vermont State Auditor
May 2009

Reform is hard work. It does not occur quickly, or easily. It occurs by identifying and giving sustained attention to the action steps needed to reach a common goal. That goal for Vermont should be "what does success look like for the state in 10 years."

No one is questioning the work ethic of the Legislature and Administration in pursuit of a balanced budget. In fact, some say they are working too hard, trying to come to large decisions, in difficult financial times on a short schedule. Yet, "this is the way it’s always been done".

When I wrote the legislative leadership from Iraq in December 2008 expressing what I saw as our responsibility and that "We need to tell people the truth, in advance, that we are going to be making brave decisions with them", I was looking for a commitment to reality.  The promises of Stimulus have arisen since then and with it a blend of both hope and false comfort. Critically, advance planning for crisis has not transpired.

Sin taxes are one example of the flaws in the current process. "The last time Vermont added a tax to beer my sales went down 17 percent, we all know where they went; across the river to New Hampshire," a small business owner conveyed to me this week.

Another example is the viable provision presented to reduce the workforce through a retirement incentive. This program is receiving positive reviews, but taken seriously too late in the process.
Meanwhile, a transparent 10 cent gas tax (without bonding) which would bring in over $10 million from out of state residents each year sits idly in the corner.

Even before the stimulus money became available to help stabilize state budgets, much information was known of the dangerous trends in government spending and the unsustainable path we are on.
It should not be a political debate that we are on a course we can neither grow nor tax our way out of. Our own David Coates, former managing partner of KPMG and respected by all, has described our mandatory expenses in Vermont as "dangerous trends requiring action."

Action requires a process, and that process demands structure.
For example, Washington State, while facing a budget deficit of $1.5 billion, in 2002 decided to foster a process of reform to address the budget crisis they faced, which is similar to what we are facing in Vermont now and will face for the next few years. Over a 10 week period, using a consultants help, the Legislature and Administration agreed to shift the focus from spending cuts and tax increases to finding the best possible result for the citizens of Washington. They: 1.) got a grip on the real problem 2) identified the dollars available for the budget 3) set priorities on what the citizens most wanted from the government and 4) "paid for those Government services" based on the dollars available.
We can do this too.

Vermont is long overdue for a process that starts early, with compassion but without emotion, that can end with a shared success. Please look closely at the current process, how cuts and tax increases arise. Listen to statements like "everything is on the table." Everyone should get a front row seat to this format because it must soon become a "remember when."  

Reform is hard. If it were easy, everyone would do it.





Newsroom
Press Releases
News Articles
Photo Gallery
Power Point Presentations
Commentary: Decision-making process must change with the times
Review of Autism Spending
Updated Hotline Numbers for Reporting Possible Fraud or Government Savings
Commentary: A year of new challenges and opportunities
Agency of Transportation Rail Report Press Release
Letter to Vermonters from State Auditor Tom Salmon
Auditor Praises County Sheriffs' Departments for Financial Turnaround
Vermont Employment Growth Incentive Program Audit Report is Issued
Vermont Employment Incentive Program Audit
State's Audit to be Complete by Dec. 31
Vermont State Colleges
Audit Finds Bioterrorism Preparedness Grants Lacked Oversight from Vermont Department of Health
Vermont Municipal Advisory Commission Kicks Off Training Sessions
Commentary: Auditor Tom Salmon Speaks on the Vermont Lottery
State Auditor on Sheriff Bonus Policies
Advice on Cash Management Offered to Towns
2006 Single Audit Report Lists State Agencies That Received Federal Funding
New Medicaid Audit Examines Claims Processing and Improper Payments
Medicaid Audit Examines Claims Processing and $900,000 in Potential Improper Payments
Auditor's Office to Assist in Isle LaMotte Investigation
State Auditor's Office Passes Key National Review
Auditor's Office Passes Key National Peer Review
Welcome from State Auditor Tom Salmon
Auditor Tom Salmon Establishes Advisory Commission
Salmon Eyes Uniform Accounting System for Sheriffs
Medicaid Pharmacy Audit
Access to Public Records & Documents  |  Vermont Public Meetings Law  |  Vermont Statutes Online  |  Vermont.gov  |  Privacy Policy  |  Site Map  |  Home

132 State Street    Montpelier, VT 05633-5101
Phone: 802.828.2281   Toll-free: 1.877.290.1400   Fax: 802.828.2198   Email:


Designed and powered by Cambium Group, LLC